Share from 0:00
0:00
/

The Guest Who Overstayed His Welcome

Hans Christian Andersen, Charles Dickens, and the dual fate and obligation of hospitality. Plus: ten copies of The Law of the Sublime to give away.

A note before we begin: this week’s video was meant to be longer, but tech issues plague me, and only the opening minute survived. The full story is below.

Good morning, friends,

This month and next, through Christmas, I’m beginning a series on hospitality: what it is, why it matters, and how we can harness its power as a high and noble expression of civility, grounded in human dignity, to heal our broken world.

Our family loves hospitality. We host at least once or twice a week: dinner parties, cocktail parties, friends and their children around our table. It is part of the fabric of our family life. But as we all know from experience, hospitality can be beautiful, or it can be frustrating, even vexing, as anything involving other human beings can be.

I love that our words hospitality and hostility share a root. The Latin hospes meant both host and guest; its cousin hostis meant a stranger, and then an enemy. Host and guest share a fate. The very same encounter can produce joy and flourishing, or it can produce hostility.

Today, a story of hospitality that began beautifully and went awry.

The guest who stayed five weeks

Hans Christian Andersen, photographed by Thora Hallager, 1869
Hans Christian Andersen, photographed by Thora Hallager, 1869

The year was 1857. Hans Christian Andersen, the beloved Danish author of The Little Mermaid, The Ugly Duckling, and so many stories that shaped our childhoods (and, I hope, our children’s), was a devoted admirer of Charles Dickens, author of Great Expectations and A Christmas Carol, which our family revisits every Christmas. The two struck up a correspondence, and Dickens invited Andersen to stay with his family at Gad’s Hill, their home in Kent.

Andersen was elated. He would not only meet his idol; he would live under his roof.

Charles Dickens, photographed by Herbert Watkins in 1858, the year after Andersen’s visit
Charles Dickens, photographed by Herbert Watkins in 1858, the year after Andersen’s visit

He was invited for two weeks. He stayed five.

Things began well, then soured quickly. Andersen brought his Danish expectations to an English household; he reportedly expected Dickens’s eldest son to shave him, as was the custom at home. And the Dickens household was in turmoil. Within a year, Charles and Catherine Dickens would separate. Andersen seemed oblivious. It was hardly an ideal time for a two-week visit, let alone five.

To his face, the family was pleasant. Behind his back, they gritted their teeth. Dickens’s daughter Kate later called him “a bony bore” who “stayed on and on.” After he finally left, Dickens pinned a card to the mirror in the guest room:

“Hans Andersen slept in this room for five weeks — which seemed to the family AGES!”

Andersen returned to Denmark believing the visit a triumph. He wrote warm letters of thanks and tried to keep the friendship alive. Dickens never answered. Andersen was devastated. This was his idol, and he thought it had all gone so well.

What Andersen and Dickens teach us

With Thanksgiving next week and Christmas ahead, here is what I take from their story.

For the guest: when in Rome, do as the Romans do. Don’t carry your own customs and expectations into someone else’s home; adapt to your hosts. And if you are staying a while, go above and beyond. Don’t expect to be waited on hand and foot. Pitch in, contribute, become part of the household. I suspect that alone would have let the Dickens family delight in Andersen rather than endure him.

For the host: welcome generously, and be honest. Opening your home to anyone, for any length of time, is a generous act. But as Benjamin Franklin put it, “Guests, like fish, begin to smell after three days.” Dickens never told Andersen, gently or otherwise, that it was time to go.

This gets at a central argument of The Soul of Civility: civility carries a dual obligation. It means respecting others enough to tell them hard truths, and respecting ourselves enough to have boundaries and to say no. Sometimes the most civil thing we can do is say, kindly and candidly, “It’s time,” to preserve the relationship before things go off the rails. Dickens and Andersen never reconciled. Perhaps they could have, had there been a forthright, honest conversation early on.

A practice for this week

A friend who is hosting 35 people for Thanksgiving recently asked me for hosting advice. My counsel: don’t do things for others that will cause you to resent them. Ask for help. Invite guests to bring a dish or take on a meal. Delegate, and make sure you are enjoying yourself, too. Setting expectations in advance is a loving thing to do, for your guests and for your family, and far better than gritting your teeth through the weekend.

So before your guests arrive this Thanksgiving, decide one thing you will ask of them, and ask early.

An invitation

Tell me a story of hospitality gone beautifully— or one gone awry. What did you learn? What boundaries will you set? What practice has set you up for vibrant gatherings? Share it in the comments below. I’d love to hear it.

And if your table becomes a place for conversation across difference this season, join the Porching Challenge and add your gathering to the Porching Map.

Two more things

A Sublime giveaway. I have ten copies of Robert Greene’s The Law of the Sublime to give away. To enter, reply to this email with the subject line “Sublime” and tell me about a moment you encountered the sublime.

A live conversation with Robert Greene. In the coming weeks, Robert and I will sit down for a live conversation, exclusive to paid subscribers of Civic Renaissance, released afterward as a podcast. If you would like to be there live, consider becoming a paid subscriber.

And for a limited time, the Kindle edition of The Soul of Civility is just $1.99.

I like to joke that my book is an ideal gift for your best friend or your worst enemy — which sometimes, as in the case of Dickens / Andersen — is the same person!

Next week: Eumaeus, the humble swineherd in Homer’s Odyssey who welcomed a ragged beggar to his fire, not knowing he was Odysseus.

With warmth and gratitude,

Lexi

Discussion about this video

User's avatar

Ready for more?