Regarding one of Hudson’s reminders of “what civility isn’t”:
“But some ideas aren’t just wrong—they’re dangerous. Civility doesn’t ask us to tolerate the intolerable. It demands that we condemn evil without dehumanizing those who perpetuate it.”
I paused at this. It reveals a deeper tension in Hudson’s approach to civility. On the surface, she makes a fair and admirable point: disagreement is inevitable, and we should handle it without contempt. But then she draws a clear line—some views are too “dangerous” to be tolerated. That’s where things get complicated.
To me, this move turns civility into something else: a way of filtering who gets to participate in public discourse, not based on how they speak, but on what they believe. The speaker still claims the moral high ground—condemning without dehumanizing—but the gate is already closed.
Oxford's Teresa Bejan, in her book "Mere Civility: Disagreement and the Limits of Toleration," is helpful here. She looks to Roger Williams, the seventeenth-century dissenter who believed that real pluralism means tolerating even the people whose views you find outrageous, heretical, or offensive. His “mere civility” does not ask for respect, even for respect of liberty! It asks for the bare minimum of forbearance—enough to keep the conversation going.
No wonder he’s often called the Father of American Pluralism. In Rhode Island, Williams built a society where even those he believed were bound for hell had a place in public life. Their right to speak and participate wasn’t contingent on being “reasonable” or “moral”—it was part of what civility demanded.
I don’t doubt Hudson’s sincerity. Her tone is warm, and her desire to elevate the national conversation is clearly genuine. But when civility becomes entangled with moral gatekeeping—when we’re told to “condemn evil” but not dehumanize, as if those lines are always easy to draw—it stops being a tool for inclusion and starts functioning as a boundary-setting exercise.
To be honest, I find myself drawn to Hudson’s eloquence. But I also think it’s ill-suited to the messy, angry, polarized world we’re actually living in.
The trouble with high-minded civility is that it still decides who gets to speak—and who must be spoken for. - This is old-fashioned conservatism dressed up in its Sunday best.
Correction: "Moralistic conservatism" is better than "old-fashioned" which is too inclusive: it tightens the focus to the moral gatekeeping impulse—often policing conduct through elevated language. It pinpoints the tone and structure of Hudson’s argument more exactly.
Hey--thanks. I have worried that some might construe my remarks as a putdown of Civic Renaissance instead of a caveat that I trusted Alexandra Hudson would welcome, in keeping with her whole philosophy--and indeed she did from her own response, whatever her "conservative" background!
Increasingly, I find labels like “conservative” or “liberal” don’t neatly fit the discussion or issue at hand, and can create their own lens of bias by introducing them to the conversation. So much has been politicized that wiping a slate clean to discuss something from the ground up can result in a wonderfully fresh approach and analysis. The world is often much more nuanced than the binary political lens. Some of the classic rules of civility might open doors to some of those thoughtful conversations.
This is an important distinction you make—poorly understood by many people who insist that we must respect their beliefs. We must only respect their liberty and not their bad ideas and beliefs.
Regarding one of Hudson’s reminders of “what civility isn’t”:
“But some ideas aren’t just wrong—they’re dangerous. Civility doesn’t ask us to tolerate the intolerable. It demands that we condemn evil without dehumanizing those who perpetuate it.”
I paused at this. It reveals a deeper tension in Hudson’s approach to civility. On the surface, she makes a fair and admirable point: disagreement is inevitable, and we should handle it without contempt. But then she draws a clear line—some views are too “dangerous” to be tolerated. That’s where things get complicated.
To me, this move turns civility into something else: a way of filtering who gets to participate in public discourse, not based on how they speak, but on what they believe. The speaker still claims the moral high ground—condemning without dehumanizing—but the gate is already closed.
Oxford's Teresa Bejan, in her book "Mere Civility: Disagreement and the Limits of Toleration," is helpful here. She looks to Roger Williams, the seventeenth-century dissenter who believed that real pluralism means tolerating even the people whose views you find outrageous, heretical, or offensive. His “mere civility” does not ask for respect, even for respect of liberty! It asks for the bare minimum of forbearance—enough to keep the conversation going.
No wonder he’s often called the Father of American Pluralism. In Rhode Island, Williams built a society where even those he believed were bound for hell had a place in public life. Their right to speak and participate wasn’t contingent on being “reasonable” or “moral”—it was part of what civility demanded.
I don’t doubt Hudson’s sincerity. Her tone is warm, and her desire to elevate the national conversation is clearly genuine. But when civility becomes entangled with moral gatekeeping—when we’re told to “condemn evil” but not dehumanize, as if those lines are always easy to draw—it stops being a tool for inclusion and starts functioning as a boundary-setting exercise.
To be honest, I find myself drawn to Hudson’s eloquence. But I also think it’s ill-suited to the messy, angry, polarized world we’re actually living in.
The trouble with high-minded civility is that it still decides who gets to speak—and who must be spoken for. - This is old-fashioned conservatism dressed up in its Sunday best.
Correction: "Moralistic conservatism" is better than "old-fashioned" which is too inclusive: it tightens the focus to the moral gatekeeping impulse—often policing conduct through elevated language. It pinpoints the tone and structure of Hudson’s argument more exactly.
A nuanced discussion rather than clear “rules” for certain, appreciate your contribution to the topic.
Hey--thanks. I have worried that some might construe my remarks as a putdown of Civic Renaissance instead of a caveat that I trusted Alexandra Hudson would welcome, in keeping with her whole philosophy--and indeed she did from her own response, whatever her "conservative" background!
Increasingly, I find labels like “conservative” or “liberal” don’t neatly fit the discussion or issue at hand, and can create their own lens of bias by introducing them to the conversation. So much has been politicized that wiping a slate clean to discuss something from the ground up can result in a wonderfully fresh approach and analysis. The world is often much more nuanced than the binary political lens. Some of the classic rules of civility might open doors to some of those thoughtful conversations.
Agreed. That was a strong eye-rolling moment for me.
This is an important distinction you make—poorly understood by many people who insist that we must respect their beliefs. We must only respect their liberty and not their bad ideas and beliefs.
Great post.
Oh this article is so good! What a refreshing perspective! We can show up with our authentic self fearlessly but maintain respect for others!